Bank-statement loans: how self-employed buyers qualify when their tax returns show less than they make

Why did my bank say no when I make good money?

Because the bank read your tax returns, and your tax returns were built to do one thing: lower your taxes. Your accountant wrote off everything they could across the last two years, which is exactly their job. The trouble is that a mortgage wants the opposite, so those two goals fight each other. A bank that only reads line 31 sees the number after every write-off, and on paper that number looks thin even when the deposits hitting your account every month say otherwise. That's the file I'd rather show a lender: twelve months of business bank statements, not the tax version of you.

I've done this for 21 years here in San Diego. I see this file all the time. It's never a question of whether the person makes money.

Here's one I think about a lot. A self-employed contractor came to me after his bank turned him down. His tax returns showed about half of what he really earned, because his accountant wrote off everything he legally could.

We skipped his tax returns completely. His bank had read line 31, seen what was left after his accountant's write-offs, and said no. We used twelve months of his business bank statements instead, so the lender counted the deposits that actually hit his account. Then we matched him with a lender whose rulebook likes self-employed borrowers, and he closed in about five weeks at a payment he was comfortable with. Every file moves at its own speed, so I can't promise anyone five weeks. But his bank's no was one lender's answer, not the market's.

How does a bank-statement loan figure my income?

Here's how a bank-statement loan actually works. The lender never opens your tax returns. All those write-offs your accountant took, the ones that made your income look thin, just don't come into it. Nobody's reading line 31. What they read is your business bank account: the deposits that actually hit it, month after month. For a lot of self-employed people, that's a very different number, and it's the one that gets you approved.

1. You send twelve months of business bank statements.
2. The lender adds up the business deposits and sets aside anything that isn't income, like a transfer from your own savings.
3. It takes out an allowance for business costs, because not every dollar that comes in is yours to keep.
4. What's left, divided by 12, becomes your monthly income for the loan.

Here's the math with made-up round numbers, so you can check it yourself. Say your returns show $60,000 of net income for the year. That's what's left after your accountant wrote off everything they could, which is exactly what you pay them to do. Divide by twelve and you get $5,000 a month. A bank that only reads line 31 stops right there. It doesn't look at what actually hit your business account, or how many months your deposits ran well past that. $5,000 is the number it counts, and your whole approval gets built on it. That's why I'd rather not send your file to a lender like that. A few of the lenders I work with will skip the returns, read twelve months of your bank statements, and count the deposits instead.

Now here's where the bank statements earn their keep. Say your business account took in $240,000 in deposits over those same twelve months. Some of that is your cost of doing business, so a lender won't count all of it. A lot of the ones I work with knock off 50% for your kind of work, which leaves $120,000 a year. Divide by 12 and you're at $10,000 a month. That's double what your returns showed, and it's the same you, same business, same money. It's just a lender that's reading your deposits instead of line 31.

That 50% is just for the example. It's not a fixed number. Each lender sets its own expense allowance, and it depends on what kind of business you run. A consultant working from a laptop and a contractor buying lumber every week won't get the same treatment, and they shouldn't. Some lenders read your deposits generously, and some take a bigger cut before they'll call it income. Knowing which lender will read your business the kindest way is most of my job.

How many years of returns do I need for a bank-statement loan?

For this kind of loan, the returns usually aren't the income document at all. The statements are. Twelve months is the version I use most, and some lenders ask for a longer stretch.

Every lender I send your file to is still going to want proof that your business is real and that it's been open a while: a business license, a CPA letter, something with a date on it. Where they draw the line on "a while" isn't the same from one lender to the next. Plenty of them want two full years, period. A few I work with will take twelve months if you did the same kind of work as a W-2 employee before you went out on your own. So one will look at your time in business and pass, and another will look at the exact same history and say yes. If you're worried you haven't been at it long enough, that's not a reason to sit and wait. It's a reason to let me shop it.

Do lenders hate self-employed people?

Some banks will work with you. Plenty won't, and I see it every week. A bank can only offer you its own rulebook, and some of those rulebooks were written for one kind of borrower: a W-2, one employer, one paycheck, one number on one line of the tax return. If your income comes from a business, your accountant probably wrote off everything they could. That's smart for taxes. It also makes your return look thin to an underwriter who only reads that one line. That's not a judgment on you or on how you handle money. It's a mismatch between your file and that bank's rules. You just walked into the wrong building. I work with lenders down the street who'd rather see your business bank statements anyway.

A bank can only show your file to one rulebook: its own. I'm a broker, so I can take that exact same file to a network of wholesale lenders, and they don't all read it the same way. Last week I had two of them look at one borrower, same income, same credit, same house. One said no. The other approved it and beat the first quote by a quarter point. After nearly two decades of this, I know which files quietly die at retail banks: the bank-statement loan built on twelve months of business deposits instead of W-2s, the asset-based loan, the non-warrantable condo. Those are loans we close. And some of those lenders don't just tolerate self-employed borrowers with a couple years of heavy write-offs. They go looking for them.

What does a bank-statement loan cost compared with a regular loan?

Here's the part nobody likes hearing. A bank-statement loan usually costs more than a standard loan. The rate tends to run higher, and some lenders will want a bigger down payment before they'll look past the tax returns. That's the price of a lender agreeing to read your deposits instead of line 31. For a lot of self-employed borrowers it's still worth it, because the alternative is the bank's no. But I'd rather you know the tradeoff now than find out at closing.

That's why I tell people the lowest rate isn't always the loan that costs you least. I see it every month: one quote comes in a quarter point lower, and then you flip to page 2 and the points and lender fees in Section A eat the savings. So get at least two Loan Estimates and put them side by side. Compare them line by line: the rate, the APR on page 3, the lender fees, the points. Then go back to page 1 and look at the projected payment, what actually leaves your account every month. That number matters more than the price of the house.

When is the answer no?

Sometimes it is, and if that's where your file lands, I'd rather you hear it from me on the first call than from an underwriter after you've already sent everything in. Here's where I slow down and look harder before I tell you yes:#

• Your deposits swing hard and the last few months dropped off.
• Big deposits you can't explain or document.
• Business and personal money are mixed so tightly that nobody can tell which is which.
• The business is too new for any lender in my network to count yet.

If one of those sounded like you, don't treat the bank's answer as the last word. It was one lender reading one rulebook, and last week I watched a second lender approve the exact file a first one turned down, then beat its quote by a quarter point. Send me what you've got, whatever you gave the bank: two years of returns, a recent pay stub, the denial letter if they sent one. I'll tell you plainly which piece is stopping the file. Usually it's one thing: the write-offs dragging down line 31, the job change, or the credit hit. Then I'll tell you what a lender would need to see to say yes, whether that's twelve months of business bank statements instead of tax returns or a clean twelve months since the credit dip, and whether it's something we can fix this month or something we just have to wait out.

One thing I'm not going to do is tell you how to file your taxes, or whether to write off less next year so line 31 looks bigger to a lender. That's your CPA's call, not mine. Every dollar you stop deducting is a dollar you pay the IRS on, and it's also a dollar a lender gets to count. That's a real tradeoff, and your CPA is the one who should weigh it. What I can do is get on a call with them, with your last two years of returns and those twelve months of bank statements in front of both of us, so we're looking at the same numbers and nobody's guessing.

What should I do before I look at houses?

Before you sit down with a lender, know what you can borrow. The free calculators on our site give you an estimate of your borrowing range and the real monthly payment in a few minutes, with no credit pull. Then text me. I'll run your numbers against the lenders I work with that take twelve months of bank statements instead of tax returns. Those are the files a bank reading line 31 turns down. No pressure.

My rule is simple. If your returns show a lot less than your deposits because your accountant wrote off everything they could, don't take one bank's no as final. That bank is reading line 31 and stopping there. Pull the last twelve months of business bank statements, let me find a lender that counts the deposits that actually hit your account, and compare at least two loan estimates line by line before you pick a house or a payment. Last week two lenders looked at the same file and one beat the other by a quarter point.

Questions people ask